Advertisement
Advertisement

Rena Brodhurst Declines Medal of Honor in Bill’s Current Form, Asks Bryan to Veto It Over Errors

Former St. Croix Avis publisher Rena Brodhurst says lawmakers passed a Medal of Honor bill without seeking her input, leaving errors about her birth date, family history, career and community work that she now wants Governor Albert Bryan Jr. to veto.

  • Staff Consortium
  • November 16, 2026
comments
1 Comments
Rena Brodhurst, left, and the St. Croix Avis building. The longtime publisher is asking Gov. Albert Bryan Jr. to veto legislation honoring her, citing factual errors in the bill.

Rena Brodhurst, left, and the St. Croix Avis building. The longtime publisher is asking Gov. Albert Bryan Jr. to veto legislation honoring her, citing factual errors in the bill.

ST. CROIX — Rena Brodhurst, the longtime publisher and owner of The St. Croix Avis, is asking Governor Albert Bryan Jr. to veto legislation awarding her the Virgin Islands Medal of Honor, saying the bill misrepresents her life, her family’s history and her stewardship of the newspaper.

Advertisement

In a letter shared with The Consortium, Brodhurst said she was grateful for the recognition but could not accept the honor under legislation containing what she described as factual errors. She also alleged that lawmakers proceeded without seeking her input and after she had asked the bill’s sponsor, Senator Novelle E. Francis Jr., to stop it.

“However, I’m unable to accept this great honor in its current inaccurate form,” she wrote. “Had I been given an opportunity to provide input, I’m sure the Legislature would have gotten it right and we would not be faced with this dilemma at this moment.”

Bill 36-0319 was among the honors measures approved during the November 12 legislative session, as previously reported by The Consortium. It recognizes Brodhurst’s contributions to journalism and the preservation of Virgin Islands history and culture. 

Advertisement

The version posted on the Legislature’s bill-tracking website provides for a gold Medal of Honor and a permanent plaque. It also contains the biographical passages challenged in her letter. 

Brodhurst said Francis apologized to her on September 28, explaining that he believed his staff had communicated with her about the legislation. According to her account, the only notice she received from his staff was that a hearing would take place the following week and that testifiers had already been selected.

She said she obtained the proposed bill from another source the day after the hearing and asked Francis to withdraw it because of the errors.

“Sen. Francis never responded to my request,” she wrote.

Among her objections is the birth date recorded in the bill, which she said is incorrect. She expressed concern that placing an inaccurate date in law could create confusion involving her identity and future Social Security applications.

She also disputed the account of the newspaper’s acquisition. The bill identifies Montclair Creque as one of the people who purchased the Avis alongside her father, Canute A. Brodhurst Sr., and Ariel Melchior. Brodhurst said it names the wrong member of the Creque family, although her letter does not identify the correct individual.

The letter challenges the bill’s description of her community support as well. Brodhurst said she did not financially support Little League baseball beyond providing routine newspaper coverage. Her contributions instead supported youth basketball through collaboration with Johnny Clenance, she said.

Brodhurst also rejected the statement that she guided the newspaper through eight governors’ administrations, saying she was still a child during the early elected administrations. She disputed the characterization that she assumed leadership without formal newspaper training, pointing to instruction from her father and her business-management degree.

Another objection concerns former Avis managing editor Eunice Bedminster. Brodhurst said Bedminster was one of several managing editors employed during her father’s and her own tenure and that the bill confuses the history of the Avis with that of the Virgin Islands Daily News.

The posted bill contains an internal inconsistency on that point: its Bedminster paragraph describes a 95-year history for the Avis, while other passages recognize the newspaper’s 180-year history. VIC’s earlier reporting on the Avis’s closure likewise documented its founding in 1844 and its approximately 180 years of publication. 

Despite her objections, Brodhurst thanked the senators who supported the legislation and those who congratulated her. She asked Bryan to include her letter in his veto message.

Advertisement

“For the sake of historical accuracy, I pray that you will kindly veto this bill and use my letter as part of your veto message,” she wrote. “As I move forward in life, I only have my reputation and my story.

Get the latest news straight to your phone with the VI Consortium app.

Advertisements

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement