Yacht Haven Seeks Court-Ordered Eviction of St. Thomas Social Over Nearly $200K in Unpaid Rent

Yacht Haven USVI has asked the court to evict St. Thomas Social, alleging nearly $200,000 in unpaid rent and fees. The restaurant received default and eviction notices this spring but remains on the property past the May 2 deadline, court records show.

  • Janeka Simon
  • May 30, 2025
comments
8 Comments

St. Thomas Social.

On Friday, Yacht Haven USVI appealed to the courts to remove tenant St. Thomas Social from its premises, after the restaurant allegedly racked up unpaid rent and fees to the tune of almost $200,000.

A two-page filing in the V.I. Superior Court says that Social Hospitality Group, which does business in the territory as St. Thomas Social, signed a 5-year lease for the property in December 2022. At some point along the way, the restaurant stopped paying its rent. A notice of default was sent in March of this year, however according to the complaint, no action was taken. 

An eviction notice was sent in April, Yacht Haven alleges, with a deadline of May 2, 2025 to vacate the premises. “Defendant has not vacated the Demised Premises and holds possession of the Demised Premises by force,” the complaint concludes. As a result, the court is asked to order the immediate eviction of St. Thomas Social from its current location at the expense of the booted business.

The legal action is the latest in a series of woes for St. Thomas Social owner Matthew McClafferty, a businessman with a checkered past who is currently battling several other lawsuits as well as a personal Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

A hearing on the matter has been set for June 12.

Get the latest news straight to your phone with the VI Consortium app.

Advertisements