Advertisement
Advertisement

Proposed $15 Million Mt. Welcome Hotel Site Is Subject of Competing Ownership Claims

A 0.83-acre Mt. Welcome parcel proposed for a $15 million hotel is at the center of competing deed claims. Stonehouse cites a recorded 2026 purchase, while Phoenix claims a 2019 transfer; an existing court order protects the developer’s access.

  • Ernice Gilbert
  • November 22, 2026
comments
2 Comments
Steel framing at the proposed Mt. Welcome hotel development on St. Croix. Competing claims to the project’s 0.83-acre parcel are pending in Superior Court.

Steel framing at the proposed Mt. Welcome hotel development on St. Croix. Competing claims to the project’s 0.83-acre parcel are pending in Superior Court. Photo Credit: ERNICE GILBERT, V.I. CONSORTIUM.

ST. CROIX — The 0.83-acre parcel proposed for a $15 million, 68-room hotel at Estate Mt. Welcome is at the center of a Superior Court ownership dispute, with developer Stonehouse Junction LLC claiming it purchased the land in January and Phoenix STX LLC asserting that the same property was conveyed to it in 2019.

Advertisement

The dispute pits Stonehouse Junction LLC, the developer proposing the $15 million hotel, against businessman Allenton Browne and his company, Phoenix STX LLC. Both companies claim ownership of Parcel No. 1 Estate Mt. Welcome, the 0.83-acre property identified in the hotel’s rezoning legislation, relying on separate deeds issued through the Nestor A. Paraliticci trust.

For now, a court order protects Stonehouse’s access to the property. In an order signed September 23 and entered September 24, Judge Ernest E. Morris Jr. barred Browne and Phoenix from entering the parcel or interfering with Stonehouse’s access, use and enjoyment through December 7. The order extends temporary relief; it does not finally resolve the competing ownership claims.

The litigation predates the hotel proposal’s recent presentation to lawmakers. As The Consortium reported November 10, Stonehouse principal Wally Hamed outlined plans for an extended-stay hotel near the D.C. Canegata Ballpark. The developers said financing was available, with construction projected to take 18 to 24 months after the necessary approvals. 

Advertisement

Stonehouse’s complaint, filed February 2, says it paid $250,000 for the parcel under a purchase agreement made in December 2025. A warranty deed submitted to the court names Nestor A. Paraliticci, as trustee, as the grantor and Stonehouse as the buyer. It is dated January 7, 2026, and bears a recording stamp dated January 14.

The company maintains that it purchased the land in good faith without notice of another party’s rights. It points to a seller’s title affidavit stating that no other party had an interest or right to claim an interest in the property, and to a title-insurance commitment that, according to the complaint, identified the trustee as the titleholder.

Stonehouse says the dispute became a confrontation on January 27, when Browne told its contractors to leave the property. According to the complaint, police responded, reviewed papers Browne presented and told the contractors to leave for the day, treating the ownership disagreement as a civil matter. Stonehouse alleges that Browne continued interfering with its use of the land and that the disruption delayed its development plans.

Browne and Phoenix deny Stonehouse’s central ownership and trespass allegations. In their verified answer and counterclaims, filed August 14, they contend that Nestor and Carmen Paraliticci, acting as co-trustees, conveyed the parcel to Phoenix on August 30, 2019.

A copy of that co-trustees’ deed, attached to their pleading, identifies Phoenix as the recipient of the same 0.83-acre parcel. Their filing acknowledges that the deed was not immediately recorded, citing outstanding property taxes among the reasons.

The dispute therefore also turns on what Stonehouse knew when it bought the property. Stonehouse argues that its recorded deed protects it as an innocent purchaser. Browne and Phoenix contend that Stonehouse knew of their prior interest and challenge its assertion that it bought without notice. 

The latest filing came November 21, when Browne, Phoenix and Nescar LLC requested entry of default against the Paraliticci parties and Arizona Inc., whom they brought into the litigation through third-party claims. They argue that those parties were served in August and September but failed to respond. 

Separately, the Legislature’s tracker for Bill 36-0406 records adoption of the parcel’s rezoning measure on November 12 and transmission to the governor November 13. It did not list an enactment date when reviewed.

Advertisement

The court has scheduled the combined injunction hearing and trial for December 7 at 9 a.m. The reviewed records do not establish that the ownership dispute has halted the hotel project or changed its financing.

Get the latest news straight to your phone with the VI Consortium app.

Advertisements

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement