Advertisement
Advertisement

Magistrate Recommends Dismissing Gustav James’s Claims Against VIPD, Bryan and Rhea, With Chance to Amend

A federal magistrate recommends dismissing Gustav James’s claims against VIPD, Bryan and Rhea, but would allow him to amend allegations against the two officials. The lawsuit concerns alleged excessive force during a July 2021 police encounter.

  • Staff Consortium
  • November 17, 2026
comments
0 Comments
Gustav James.

Gustav James.

ST. CROIX — A federal magistrate judge has recommended dismissing former Public Works Commissioner Gustav James’s civil-rights claims against the Virgin Islands Police Department, Governor Albert Bryan Jr. and Attorney General Gordon C. Rhea, while giving him an opportunity to amend his claims against the two officials.

Advertisement

In a November 16 report and recommendation, U.S. Magistrate Judge Emile A. Henderson III proposed dismissing the VIPD claims with prejudice because the territorial agency is not a “person” subject to suit under the federal civil-rights statute, 42 U.S.C. § 1983.

The judge found that Mr. Bryan and Mr. Rhea appeared only in the complaint’s caption, with no allegations describing their involvement. He recommended dismissing those claims without prejudice and allowing Mr. James 30 days to amend his complaint to address the deficiencies.

The report is a recommendation to the district judge, rather than a final dismissal order. It provides 14 days from receipt for written objections. 

Advertisement

Mr. James, who served as Public Works commissioner under Governor Kenneth Mapp before resigning in August 2017, is representing himself. 

His May 2025 lawsuit alleges that DEA agents and VIPD officers unlawfully entered his property during a July 2021 encounter, handcuffed him, forced him to stand in the sun and used excessive force that injured his wrist and shoulder. He seeks compensatory and punitive damages.

The latest report follows a separate November 4 recommendation concerning the federal defendants. In that report, Judge Henderson recommended dismissing Mr. James’s Federal Tort Claims Act claims without prejudice because his complaint did not allege that he had completed the required administrative claims process.

However, the judge acknowledged evidence that Mr. James had submitted an administrative claim to the DEA, that the agency denied it on November 19, 2024, and that he subsequently filed his lawsuit on time. The problem was his failure to include those facts in the complaint. Judge Henderson therefore recommended allowing him 30 days to amend that pleading as well.

Advertisement

The recommendations concern legal and pleading requirements; they do not resolve whether the alleged misconduct occurred.

Get the latest news straight to your phone with the VI Consortium app.

Advertisements

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement