Advertisement
Advertisement

Daughter Sues Oriental Bank, Alleging $60,000 From Father’s Accounts Was Diverted to Former Employee

A new complaint alleges that $60,000 intended for a deceased customer’s daughter was diverted through manager’s checks to Mylon Allen and then Jahmaira Farrell, while Oriental Bank failed to follow safeguards or investigate earlier transactions.

  • Janeka Simon
  • November 17, 2026
comments
0 Comments
Oriental Bank in Sunny Isle, St. Croix. A new lawsuit alleges a former employee diverted $60,000 owed to a deceased customer’s daughter and that the bank failed to enforce safeguards.

Oriental Bank in Sunny Isle, St. Croix. A new lawsuit alleges a former employee diverted $60,000 owed to a deceased customer’s daughter and that the bank failed to enforce safeguards. Photo Credit: V.I. CONSORTIUM.

ST. CROIX — A new lawsuit accuses a former Oriental Bank employee of diverting $60,000 intended for a deceased customer’s daughter through an unauthorized payment to another man, who allegedly transferred the money to the employee before she spent it on Las Vegas travel, jewelry and furniture.

Advertisement

Edna Smith-Gilchrist’s complaint names Oriental Bank, former employee Jahmaira Farrell and Mylon Allen as defendants. It alleges that the bank failed to follow its own transaction safeguards and missed subsequent opportunities to uncover the diversion, leaving Ms. Smith-Gilchrist unaware of her loss until October 14, 2026.

The Superior Court complaint, dated November 12, concerns proceeds from two accounts belonging to her late father, Henry Smith. It connects the alleged diversion to the same individuals previously implicated in the separate $100,000 Lennox Cato case, which The Consortium reported on in June 2025. 

According to the new complaint, Mr. Smith maintained a certificate of deposit containing $55,555.21 and a savings account holding $128,658.36. Both designated Ms. Smith-Gilchrist as beneficiary, making the combined proceeds $184,213.57.

Advertisement

Ms. Smith-Gilchrist, who lives in North Carolina, authorized her sister, Rufina Smith, to handle the account closures locally while she participated by telephone. They dealt with Ms. Farrell, whom Oriental employed as a customer service representative responsible for receiving instructions and preparing transaction documents.

The bank paid Ms. Smith-Gilchrist $124,173.57, which she believed represented the full amount owed. She says she signed no account-closing or disbursement documents and received no paperwork showing balances, deductions or how the proceeds were distributed.

The complaint alleges that Ms. Farrell instead used the account-closing process to arrange a $60,000 manager’s check payable to “Roan James” on March 1, 2022. Oriental canceled that check and issued a replacement payable to Mylon R. Allen the following day. The lawsuit alleges that Roan is Mr. Allen’s middle name and the name used by his friends and family.

Ms. Smith-Gilchrist says she does not know Mr. Allen, never authorized payment to him and that he had no beneficiary interest in either account.

According to the complaint, Mr. Allen deposited the replacement check into his Banco Popular account on March 2. On March 10, he purchased a $60,000 official check payable to Ms. Farrell, who allegedly deposited it the next day into a Bank of St. Croix account she had opened on March 3.

Within days, the lawsuit alleges, Ms. Farrell used the proceeds for airline tickets, a booking at The Palazzo at the Venetian Resort in Las Vegas, jewelry and furniture.

The complaint separately identifies an unexplained $40 difference between the combined account balances and the payments to Ms. Smith-Gilchrist and Mr. Allen.

Ms. Smith-Gilchrist also alleges failures by the bank employees responsible for approving the transactions. According to the complaint, Oriental’s Monetary Transactions Manual required two authorized signatures on manager’s checks exceeding $10,000, including a manager or operations team leader. Replacement checks were subject to the same requirements, and unexplained substitutions required immediate referral to the Compliance Department.

The lawsuit alleges that employees approved both checks without establishing the recipients’ entitlement or obtaining Ms. Smith-Gilchrist’s authorization. It further claims that the cancellation and change in payee were processed without resolving the discrepancy or referring the transaction to compliance personnel.

The complaint also challenges Oriental’s response to later discoveries involving Ms. Farrell.

It alleges that an August 2022 investigation into an unauthorized $6,000 withdrawal from Mr. Cato’s account established that Ms. Farrell had prepared the paperwork, signed his name and obtained payment in his absence. Oriental subsequently terminated her employment, according to the lawsuit.

Ms. Smith-Gilchrist contends that the findings should have prompted a review of Ms. Farrell’s earlier transactions. Such a review, she alleges, would have uncovered both the $60,000 payment from her father’s accounts and a separate $100,000 manager’s check issued to Mr. Allen from Mr. Cato’s funds in June 2022.

The complaint says Mr. Cato and his representative reported the $100,000 loss to Oriental in July 2024. Police began investigating in January 2025 and subsequently identified the earlier $60,000 transaction, obtaining its source documents through a subpoena.

The Consortium previously reported that Ms. Farrell was arrested on June 9, 2025, and Mr. Allen surrendered the following day, in connection with the separate Cato allegations. 

According to the new complaint, an Oriental Corporate Security investigator later acknowledged seeing records of the Smith transaction and recognizing Ms. Farrell’s involvement, but said the bank had not opened an investigation because Ms. Smith-Gilchrist had not submitted a claim.

She says she had not done so because she knew nothing about the payment. Her first notice allegedly came during an October 14, 2026 telephone call concerning her potential role as a witness in the Cato matter.

Represented by attorney C. Jacob Gower, Ms. Smith-Gilchrist asserts breach of contract, negligence and gross negligence against Oriental Bank, conversion against all three defendants, and civil liability for stolen property against Ms. Farrell and Mr. Allen.

She seeks recovery of the $60,000, additional recoverable losses, three times actual damages under the stolen-property claim, punitive damages, interest, costs and attorney’s fees. She also requests the additional $40 from Oriental if it was withheld without authorization and demands a jury trial.

Advertisement

The complaint presents the plaintiff’s allegations. The materials reviewed for this article did not include responses from the defendants to the new lawsuit.

Get the latest news straight to your phone with the VI Consortium app.

Advertisements

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement