ST. CROIX — Juan F. Luis Hospital fired emergency room nurse Cheryl Leddy over a return-to-work form, later acknowledged that the document was valid and agreed to compensate her for a wrongful termination, according to her union. But a settlement reached in October 2024 allegedly produced none of the promised payments, despite a hospital spreadsheet calculating more than $370,000 in lost wages.
More than two years after that agreement, the Virgin Islands State Nurses Association Collective Bargaining Unit is pursuing the compensation through Superior Court. In a renewed motion filed November 18, the union seeks entry of default against the Government of the Virgin Islands, the Department of Health and the Office of Collective Bargaining, arguing that they were served in August but failed to respond to the lawsuit.
As The Consortium reported when the lawsuit was filed in August, Leddy had been on approved medical leave when Dr. Lyle Campbell signed her return-to-work form on June 21, 2021. The name printed beneath the signature was that of his brother, Dr. Lyn Campbell, who practiced with him on St. Croix.
After JFL fired Leddy in July, the practice supplied a letter the next day explaining that she was under Lyn Campbell’s care, but Lyle Campbell had examined her and signed the form. A July 15 grievance hearing nevertheless upheld the firing, according to the complaint.
The union says hospital counsel later acknowledged that the doctors’ explanation established there had been no fraud. The parties settled on October 29, 2024, avoiding a scheduled arbitration hearing.
Payment did not follow, the lawsuit alleges. Citing financial difficulties, JFL proposed at least 60 days before an initial payment, followed by installments over several years. By December, the hospital could provide no firm payment date. Its acting counsel reiterated an intention to settle in March 2025, but the complaint says JFL became unresponsive that August.
When the union filed suit in August 2026, it alleged that Leddy had received none of the promised compensation. The dispute now encompasses both the hospital’s alleged failure to honor the settlement and the union’s contention that three government defendants have failed to answer the resulting lawsuit.
The November 18 filing followed an order denying the union’s first default request without prejudice, allowing it to renew the application. Judge Venetia Harvey Velazquez’s order noted that the hospital corporation had opposed the initial request on the grounds that it had not been properly served.
The renewed motion leaves the hospital corporation out of the default request and focuses on the government, Health Department and Office of Collective Bargaining. The union maintains that service was properly completed and that their time to respond has expired. An accompanying affidavit describes agency representatives accepting the lawsuit papers on behalf of their respective officials.
The hospital corporation, meanwhile, separately moved on November 17 to dismiss the lawsuit for failure to state a claim.
The renewed request seeks a formal entry of default for failure to respond; it does not itself establish that Leddy is entitled to a monetary judgment. The more than $370,000 identified in the lawsuit remains claimed compensation based on the hospital’s alleged calculation, rather than a court award.

