Advertisement
Advertisement

CMS Reports Higher Stroke Death Estimates at JFL and Schneider, Withholds Statistical Comparisons

Federal records put 30-day stroke mortality estimates at 23.3% at Juan F. Luis Hospital and 26% at Schneider, against 11.9% nationally. CMS withheld statistical comparisons for both hospitals as part of a broader pause affecting several quality measures.

  • Ernice Gilbert
  • November 21, 2026
comments
0 Comments
MRI and CT angiography from a published ischemic stroke case. Federal data show estimated 30-day stroke mortality above the national rate at both Juan F. Luis and Schneider hospitals. The scans are not from either hospital.

MRI and CT angiography from a published ischemic stroke case. Federal data show estimated 30-day stroke mortality above the national rate at both Juan F. Luis and Schneider hospitals. The scans are not from either hospital.

Federal data released Nov. 12 put the estimated 30-day death rate after an ischemic stroke admission at 23.3% at the Gov. Juan F. Luis Hospital and Medical Center on St. Croix and 26% at Roy Lester Schneider Hospital on St. Thomas, compared with 11.9% nationally. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services did not publish the statistical comparisons it ordinarily uses to determine whether hospital rates differ from the national figure.

Advertisement

The hospital-level data cover admissions from July 2023 through June 2025 and include 52 eligible admissions at Juan F. Luis and 51 at Schneider. The national figure covers the same period. CMS adjusts its estimates for differences in patient risk and counts deaths within 30 days of admission, whether they occur in the hospital or after discharge.

A federal notice on the November release said CMS is withholding national comparison classifications and confidence intervals for affected mortality, readmission and other measures because of problems it identified with those data. The notice said the problems did not affect the individual hospitals’ rates. The published figures show how far apart the estimates are, but the release does not establish whether the differences are statistically significant.

Of the 48 severe sepsis and septic shock cases reviewed at Schneider in 2025, about one in three (33%) met all the federal requirements for timely treatment, compared with about two in three (66%) nationally. To count, every required step had to be documented within the time allowed. A case could fall short even if the patient received treatment. The figures do not show how many patients survived.

CMS did not publish a comparable 2025 sepsis care score for Juan F. Luis. The agency flagged a shorter-than-required reporting period and said no cases met the measure’s inclusion criteria. The missing score does not establish that the hospital treated no sepsis patients that year.

Advertisement

The November update did not change the overall quality ratings previously reported by The Consortium: one star for Juan F. Luis and two stars for Schneider. CMS calculated those ratings in April from October 2025 data across five categories, including mortality, safety, readmissions, patient experience and timely care. The figures published in November give a more recent look at specific measures, not a new round of star ratings.

Get the latest news straight to your phone with the VI Consortium app.

Advertisements

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement