A new federal lawsuit alleges that Department of Licensing and Consumer Affairs Assistant Commissioner Horace Graham retaliated against Prosperity Farm and RaisingCane by withdrawing approval for six products after the businesses challenged the agency’s actions in court.
The complaint, filed Friday in the District Court of the Virgin Islands, accuses Mr. Graham of withdrawing the approvals “without notice and without a hearing,” days after senior DLCA officials were served with papers in an earlier federal case. It seeks an injunction and compensatory and punitive damages, naming Mr. Graham in both his individual and official capacities.
According to the lawsuit, DLCA initially approved labels for six RaisingCane products in July 2025. Correspondence on agency letterhead reportedly stated that the labels were approved and the products could be sold in the Virgin Islands.
The agency approved amended labels the following month, the complaint states, although that letter identified the business as Prosperity Farm & Restaurant LLC instead of RaisingCane. The amendments changed information concerning the products’ origin and proof.
RaisingCane says it relied on both letters when it began selling the products in September 2025. By 2026, the products were available in “bars, restaurants, and six grocery retailers” throughout the territory, according to the complaint.
The dispute escalated in June, when a DLCA officer allegedly warned personnel at three St. Croix supermarkets that they could face fines for continuing to carry the products. RaisingCane responded by sending its August 2025 label and sale approvals to each of its 26 client accounts, the lawsuit states.
The businesses subsequently filed a federal lawsuit alleging constitutional violations, including claims connected to the supermarket warnings and the seizure of a company tractor’s license plates. That complaint also challenged DLCA’s handling of administrative proceedings.
In that earlier filing, the businesses stated that the label approval letters had not been “revoked, withdrawn, superseded, suspended or qualified.”
The new complaint alleges that 17 days after the October lawsuit was filed, Mr. Graham emailed the businesses a seven-page letter on DLCA letterhead withdrawing any “purported approval conveyed by the August 12, 2025 communication.”
According to the correspondence quoted in the lawsuit, the statements in the August letter “were made inadvertently and prematurely.” Mr. Graham also stated that the letter was “not issued or distributed through the Department’s established review and authorization channels for final agency action.”
His correspondence characterized the withdrawal as an “administrative correction” and stated that it was “not a final denial of the pending submissions.”
The businesses challenge both the procedure and the explanation. They allege that the withdrawal came without advance notice, a hearing or information about an appeal process. They also contend that the letter cited information from the original product labels as grounds for the action, although that information was absent from the amended labels approved in August.
The complaint further argues that Mr. Graham’s letter neither mentioned nor withdrew the July approval and did not explain how two substantially similar approvals could have been issued outside the agency’s established procedures.
The new case follows a broader dispute over the businesses’ licensing and public-facing operations. In September, the Department of Health shut down Prosperity Farm’s bar, food-service and event operations after finding that required health permits and Fire/EMS approvals were missing. DLCA separately maintained that activities including operating a bar, serving alcohol and hosting events exceeded the authority of the commercial farming license. The agricultural operation itself was not ordered closed.
The businesses challenged DLCA’s licensing determination in Superior Court before pursuing the earlier federal case.
Friday’s complaint alleges First Amendment retaliation and Fourteenth Amendment due process violations. It asks the court to prohibit further retaliatory action and enforcement based on the withdrawal notice, and to hold Mr. Graham personally liable for compensatory and punitive damages arising from its issuance.

