A federal judge has rejected former Virgin Islands senator Wayne A.G. James’s attempt to overturn his fraud and embezzlement convictions, finding that he failed to establish that his attorney’s decision not to call defense witnesses violated his constitutional rights.
In a November 13 memorandum opinion, Chief District Judge Robert Molloy rejected Mr. James’s claims of an unfair trial, ineffective assistance of counsel and denial of due process. Mr. James represented himself in the challenge. The court had previously determined that an evidentiary hearing was unnecessary.
Mr. James argued that available witnesses could have supported his defense. Judge Molloy found that he had not demonstrated how their testimony would have changed the outcome, and had provided neither sworn statements from the proposed witnesses nor support that they would have agreed to testify.
The judge also rejected the contention that resting without calling witnesses necessarily amounted to inadequate representation, explaining that the government bears the burden of proving guilt.
“This trial strategy is sound and not unreasonable. Defendant simply disagrees with his counsel’s decisions,” Judge Molloy wrote.
The case arose from Mr. James’s use of public money intended for historical research while serving in the 28th Legislature. As The Consortium reported following his conviction, he obtained legislative approval to research the 1878 Fireburn and began requesting money in April 2009 for research, copying and translation of records held by the Danish National Archives.
Prosecutors said the trial evidence showed that Mr. James initially spent funds on the project but subsequently used fabricated invoices to obtain additional payments. According to the U.S. Attorney’s Office at the time, he received more than $90,000, kept approximately $70,000 for himself and used diverted money for campaign and personal expenses.
A jury convicted him in August 2018 of two counts of wire fraud and one count of federal program embezzlement. He received concurrent 30-month prison terms and three years of supervised release. The Third Circuit affirmed his convictions in 2020.
The November 13 decision leaves those convictions intact.

