Advertisement
Advertisement

St. Thomas Supermarket Gap Remains Above $100, St. Croix Near $44 in Latest DLCA Survey

Pueblo Golden Rock, Pueblo Long Bay and Pine Peace Mini Mart again posted the lowest surveyed baskets on their respective islands, while St. Thomas recorded a $119.15 gap between stores, continuing a pattern documented in VIC’s October coverage.

  • Staff Consortium
  • November 17, 2026
comments
3 Comments
St. Thomas Supermarket Gap Remains Above $100, St. Croix Near $44 in Latest DLCA Survey

Wide differences in supermarket prices persisted in the Department of Licensing and Consumer Affairs’ latest grocery survey, with the same stores retaining the lowest basket totals on their respective islands and St. Thomas again recording a gap exceeding $100.

Advertisement

The survey for the week of November 9, released Monday, November 16, found a $119.15 difference between the lowest and highest surveyed baskets on St. Thomas. That follows the $115.49 gap documented in the Consortium’s October 30 report on DLCA’s previous comparison, which covered the week of October 19. 

Pueblo Golden Rock on St. Croix, Pueblo Long Bay on St. Thomas and Pine Peace Mini Mart on St. John again recorded the lowest overall totals among participating stores.

The results reinforce the value of comparing prices ahead of Thanksgiving, but they do not establish an overall increase or decrease in grocery costs. The number of items surveyed changed between the two periods, and each island’s basket contains a different selection of products.

Advertisement

The latest comparison covered 84 items on St. Croix, 78 on St. Thomas and 43 on St. John, down from 90, 88 and 49, respectively, in the October 19 survey.

On St. Thomas, Pueblo Long Bay’s basket totaled $420.37, followed by The Market at $426.68, Pueblo Subbase at $439.50 and Food Center at $539.52.

Individual prices show why shoppers should also consider the specific products they buy. Ribeye steak was listed at $14.99 per pound at The Market, compared with $24.19 at Pueblo Subbase and $26.99 at both Pueblo Long Bay and Food Center. Food Center, despite recording the highest basket total, offered the lowest surveyed ground beef price at $4.69 per pound.

On St. Croix, Pueblo Golden Rock’s basket totaled $401.44, followed by Pueblo La Reine at $403.41, The Market at $406.45, Plaza Extra at $410.40 and Stop and Shop Supermarket at $445.37.

The $43.93 difference between the lowest and highest St. Croix baskets was similar to the $43.18 spread in the October survey. Just $8.96 separated the four lowest totals in the latest results.

On St. John, Pine Peace Mini Mart’s basket cost $287.52, compared with $301.37 at Starfish Market and $309.85 at St. John Market. The latest spread was $22.33, compared with $45.38 in October, although the changed basket prevents treating that smaller difference as a direct measure of price convergence.

St. John’s individual product prices also varied. A five-pound package of white rice cost $10.95 at St. John Market and $10.99 at Pine Peace, compared with $17.09 at Starfish. Starfish offered the lowest surveyed prices for 24-ounce white bread at $4.29 and whole wheat bread at $4.99.

Commissioner H. Nathalie Hodge announced the results as DLCA encouraged families preparing for Thanksgiving to compare prices and make economical shopping choices.

Advertisement

Consumers with questions may contact the department’s Consumer Affairs Division at 340-713-3522 on St. Croix, 340-714-3522 on St. Thomas or 340-727-3303 on St. John, or email [email protected].

Get the latest news straight to your phone with the VI Consortium app.

Advertisements

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement