ST. THOMAS — A man accused of raping three women at gunpoint between August 2016 and January 2017 has been extradited from Florida to face charges after investigators say DNA collected following an unrelated arrest linked him to the attacks.
Tyshown Belle was returned to the territory after completing a sentence at a Florida correctional facility. The V.I. Police Department said members of its Special Operations Bureau traveled to West Palm Beach on Monday, November 16, to carry out the extradition under a warrant issued in 2025. His initial bail was set at $500,000.
The case revisits a series of attacks that prompted a public search nearly a decade ago. In February 2017, The Consortium reported that police had released a suspect’s description while investigating potentially connected sexual assaults on St. Thomas’ East End, including incidents reported between August 15, 2016, and January 24, 2017.
According to police reports, the first woman told investigators that she awoke around 4 a.m. on August 15, 2016, to find an unknown man standing over her and pointing a gun at her face.
When she screamed, the man allegedly struck her in the head several times with the weapon and ordered her to be quiet. She said he covered her face with a T-shirt and pillow before raping her. The woman told police she kept her hands between the pillow and her face so she could breathe, and that she struggled to see the attacker because she was not wearing her glasses.
Afterward, the man ordered her into the bathroom to wash, according to her account. She told police she washed only lightly in an effort to appear compliant. While she was in the bathroom, the assailant removed the bedsheets and left.
The woman discovered that her cellphone was missing and sought help. A friend eventually took her to the Schneider Regional Medical Center emergency room, where she underwent a sexual assault examination. Investigators said samples sent to the FBI laboratory yielded a male DNA profile.
The second woman reported a similar attack on September 7, 2016, while she was house-sitting at a residence in Frydenhoj. She told police she awoke during the early morning hours to find an unknown man pressing against her and pointing a gun at her head.
According to investigators, the assailant forced her to perform a sexual act, covered her face with a comforter and raped her. He then ordered her into the shower, took the bedding and left. Samples collected during her subsequent sexual assault examination also yielded male DNA, which was entered into the FBI’s Combined DNA Index System, known as CODIS.
The third reported attack occurred on January 24, 2017, as a woman prepared to leave her Frydenhoj apartment complex for work shortly before 6 a.m.
She told police that an unknown man approached as she unlocked her car, pointed a gun at her and ordered her to remain quiet. He allegedly forced her toward the back gate of her home and raped her between a wall and a nearby vehicle.
The woman said the assailant took her phone but returned it after she told him she could not afford a replacement. She returned to her apartment and told her boyfriend what had happened. A subsequent sexual assault examination produced another male DNA profile that was entered into CODIS.
Police said the three women provided similar descriptions of their attacker.
Investigators identified Belle as a suspect after his February 2022 arrest in Florida on firearm and narcotics charges. A DNA sample collected in connection with that arrest was entered into the FBI database and reportedly produced a possible match to evidence from the three sexual assault examinations.
A court subsequently authorized collection of a second sample from Belle. According to investigators, further FBI testing provided strong support for identifying him as a contributor to the DNA recovered in all three cases.
An arrest warrant was issued on March 11, 2025.
The charges listed in the case include first-degree aggravated rape, first-degree rape, kidnapping for the purpose of rape, first-degree unlawful sexual contact, first- and third-degree assault, home invasion, first-degree burglary, possession of an unlicensed firearm during a crime of violence, and grand larceny.
Belle appeared before Magistrate Julie Smith Todman on Tuesday, November 17, for an advice-of-rights hearing, according to court records described in the reporting. The outcome of that hearing was not available at press time. The charges remain allegations, and Belle is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.

